The Falconer's Knot by Mary Hoffman
So I thought this was a decent story. At first it seemed like there were too many characters (as more and more are introduced in each chapter) but then you begin to see how they all intertwine. The story kept me interested - I wanted to know how it ended but I don't know if teens would "love" it and I feel like that is more of what we're looking for. So I'm leaning towards NAY.